Draft FSI 6 (liquidity risk, insurers): what changed since the May 2024 draft

Checked against the Prudential Authority's own documents, 21 October 2026 (bank paper section: 24 October). Comments to the PA close 27 November 2026 (PA-Standards@resbank.co.za, on the PA's comment template). No start date is set. This is a reading of public drafts, not legal or actuarial advice; check it against the PA's text. New on 24 October: bank paper and money market funds.

The core of the 2024 draft survived: an insurance liquidity ratio (ILR) of at least 100% over 30 days, inflows counted only up to 75% of outflows, Level 1 assets at least 60% of the HQLA portfolio, and a monthly return. What is new is the detail that makes it computable and auditable: numbers for haircuts, a single-issuer limit, uncertainty ranges, reverse stress tests, a liquidity add-on and an explicit audit duty.

What changed

TopicMay 2024 informal draft14 Oct 2026 consultation draft
Unit-linked businessThe standard does not apply to obligations where the policyholder bears the liquidity risk (para 1.3).No blanket exemption. Cash flows on unit-linked liabilities where the policyholder bears the investment risk are left out of the ILR (7.4), but the residual liquidity needs stay in scope and need HQLA (8.4). An insurer with unit-linked business can ask the PA in writing for a Level 1 share below 60% (8.10). The PA says this answers insurers' request for an exemption (Statement of need, 5.8.3.1).
Stress testingSevere but plausible scenarios, assessed at entity and group level across the time ladder (5.1, 5.4).Acute stress up to three months and protracted stress up to twelve (6.3); the cumulative stressed net cash flow at each horizon, and sufficiency shown over one month (6.4); liquidity modelled as a consequence of primary events, with causal pathways (6.6.2); a 95% confidence interval or a sensitivity range for every scenario (6.9); a reverse stress test where the stock of liquid assets runs out (6.12, 6.13); the PA may prescribe a standardised scenario by notice (6.11).
The ILRAt least 100% over 30 days; inflows capped at 75% of outflows (7.1, 7.2.1).Same formula and cap (7.4), plus: "an appropriate buffer" (7.1); minimum percentages the PA may set at any time (7.2); results shown with 95% intervals or sensitivity ranges (7.3).
What counts as HQLAA table of asset types and rating bands. Haircuts: "the appropriate haircut", no numbers. SA government instruments are HQLA whatever the table says (6.5).Moved to a separate determination notice: 16 items, haircuts of 0% (Level 1), 15% (Level 2a) and 50% (Level 2b), unrated assets only as item 16, foreign-currency assets only up to the net outflows in that currency (Notice 2.7). Rating rules: the less favourable of two ratings, or of the two best of more than two (8.14, 8.15); national scale for SA issuers, global scale for others (Notice 2.5).
Rating thresholdsCorporate and public-sector debt in Level 2b down to BBB+ / Baa1; covered bonds to BBB-; equities "publicly traded on a major exchange".Corporate and public-sector debt in Level 2b now down to BBB- / Baa3; covered bonds unchanged; equities must be in a major index, not issued by a financial institution or the insurer's group, and traded in a deep and active market. Money market funds must hold only items 1 to 6 and be redeemable within 30 days.
ConcentrationNone beyond the Level 1 share.New: no single issuer above 20% of the portfolio, SA government bonds excepted, and diversification by type, issuer and jurisdiction (8.9). Level 1 at least 60% is unchanged (8.8).
Who signs whatThe head of risk management and the head of the actuarial function both opine on the ILR (2.4). The auditor's duty is stated generally (2.5).The head of the actuarial function opines on the accuracy of the ILR and the appropriateness of its assumptions (3.5). The auditor must obtain evidence on the composition of the HQLA and the ILR calculation and report material non-compliance (3.6). Risk management and internal audit review the calculation (4.4).
ReportingMonthly liquidity returns, and an annual liquidity risk management report with the ORSA (Table 2, 9.1).Monthly Liquidity Return through the Umoja portal within 20 business days of month end (Annexure E). No separate annual report: the ORSA must carry defined liquidity content (10.3; the guidance notice, 4.4, says so).
Liquidity add-onNot there.New: the PA may require a higher ILR, more HQLA, or HQLA of a given composition, currency or location, after giving reasons and a chance to respond, and must review it at least yearly (10.5 to 10.7).
Contingency funding planBoard-approved, tested annually.Also tested against standardised, tailored and reverse stress scenarios and updated on the results; must show it can hold the ILR at 100% or above (9.2.6, 9.2.7).
Support documentsThe draft standard only.A guidance notice with illustrative stress scenarios (Annexure B), a statement of need and impact (C), the haircuts notice (D), the reporting notice and the return workbook (E). The PA's impact study had a low response, and it will use the consultation to collect data on cash flows, the ILR, derivatives, securities lending and the contingency funding plan.
Start dateBlank (the draft still carried a 2018 version table).Blank; the statement of need says the date is "yet to be communicated" (6.2).

Bank paper and money market funds: what Table 1 lets in

Added 24 October 2026. This is my reading of Annexure D (Table 1) and the return's line definitions. The Authority may intend something else, so each point is a question for the PA, not a ruling.

Three things in the draft's table of qualifying assets catch an insurer that keeps its liquidity in money market funds and bank accounts.

  1. A money market fund is Level 1 only if it holds nothing but items 1 to 6. Item 7 reads: "Invested solely in assets qualifying under items 1 to 6, and redeemable within 30 calendar days". Items 1 to 6 are cash and demand deposits, Reserve Bank deposits and securities, SA government securities, foreign government securities rated AA- or better, and a list of supranational issuers. Two rand funds publish this:
    • Old Mutual Money Market Fund, fact sheet at 30 April 2026: 2.5% in cash and the rest in maturity bands of up to 12 months. By issuer: Republic of South Africa 39.4%, five banks 54.3%, three corporates 4.7%, other 1.6%.
    • Nedgroup Investments Money Market Fund, credit analysis at 30 September 2026: banks 82.6%, Republic of South Africa 12.2%, corporates 5.2%, modified duration 0.15 years, so it is not all on-demand cash.
    Both also hold corporate paper, which is not in items 1 to 6, and neither document says which instruments the bank money is in. On the wording, neither fund meets item 7 on the corporate paper alone, and the bank money would fail too unless it is all on demand. Question for the PA: is a money market fund meant to be tested on its holdings, or may a regulated rand money market fund count as Level 1 or Level 2a?
  2. Bank NCDs, fixed deposits and senior bank bonds fit no item except 16. Item 1 takes deposits only if they are "withdrawable on demand". Items 10 and 12 take corporate debt only from a "non-financial entity". Covered bonds (11 and 13) are not NCDs. What is left is item 16, "other assets" shown to have low credit risk, low volatility, ready marketability and a proven record as a source of liquidity under stress: Level 2b, with a 50% haircut. Question for the PA: is that the intended home for short-dated bank paper?
  3. Cash and deposits at one bank count toward the 20% issuer limit. Paragraph 8.9 excepts only SA government bonds. A portfolio with no government bonds needs at least five issuers to keep each under 20%. Question for the PA: is a money market fund one issuer, or does the limit look through to the banks inside it? The calculator counts the fund as one issuer.

What it does to a small insurer

"Small Short-Term Ltd" is made up. It holds R50m in one money market fund, R20m on call at Bank A and R10m in SA government bonds. Under stress its 30-day outflows are R130m and its inflows R80m, so net outflows are R50m (the 75% inflow cap does not bind).

How the money market fund is readAdjusted HQLAInsurance liquidity ratio
Level 1: it meets item 7R80m160%
Item 16: Level 2b, 50% haircutR55m110%
Does not qualifyR30m60%

The 20% issuer test fails in all three readings. With the fund eligible it is 62.5% of the portfolio and Bank A 25%; without it, Bank A alone is 67%. A larger insurer that holds mostly government bonds moves far less: the calculator's worked example, Example Life, goes from 130.5% to 126.1% with its fund as item 16, or 121.8% without it.

To see it yourself, open Small Short-Term Ltd in the calculator, go to the HQLA tab and either untick "Invested solely in assets of items 1 to 6" on the fund or change its class to "Other assets (item 16)" and tick the box that appears. Nothing you do there leaves your browser.

Questions that came up while building the calculator

These are my reading of the public drafts, where the text is silent, inconsistent or hard to compute. The calculator takes the cautious reading in each case. Verify each against the PA's text and your advisers before putting it in a comment letter.

  1. Development banks above AA-. Item 5 covers foreign governments, central banks and public sector entities rated AA- or better. Item 8 covers those and development banks not on the Note 1 list, but only "below AA-". A development bank outside Note 1 rated AA- or better fits neither item.
  2. Market value or value after haircut? Paragraphs 8.8 (Level 1 at least 60%) and 8.9 (20% issuer limit) say "of the portfolio" without saying which value. The two readings can pass and fail the same portfolio. The calculator shows both.
  3. Does the 20% limit apply to cash held with one bank? Paragraph 8.9 excepts only SA government bonds. Deposits with one bank and deposits with the SA Reserve Bank are otherwise single-issuer exposures. The calculator counts them.
  4. At least 100%, or the PA's minimum? Paragraph 7.1 says at least 100%; 7.2 says not below the minimum percentages the PA determines at any time. Which governs, and when would a different percentage be set?
  5. Foreign currency, per currency or in total. Notice 2.7 limits non-rand HQLA to the net outflows "in that currency". The return's ILR sheet has one memo line for all non-rand HQLA (line 107) and one for all non-rand net outflows (line 108), and subtracts the excess of one over the other. With two currencies the two readings give different ratios. The calculator follows the Notice and tells you when the workbook would differ.
  6. "Other assets" in Level 2a. On the return's ILR sheet, "Other assets" appears under Level 2a with a 0.85 factor (line 98) and again under Level 2b with 0.5 (line 106). The Notice makes item 16 Level 2b at 50%, and the line definitions for both lines describe item 16. Several row labels in column A still carry the 2024 wording while the definitions sheet follows the Notice.
  7. An ILR of 0% when there are no net outflows. The return computes the ratio as IFERROR(HQLA / net outflows, 0). If net stressed outflows are zero or negative it shows 0%, which reads as a breach. The calculator shows "undefined" instead.
  8. Transfers between the two portfolios. The return has an inflow line for transfers from the shareholder portfolio into the policyholder portfolio. If the matching outflow is also reported, both totals grow by the same amount, and when the 75% cap binds the net outflow grows by a quarter of it. Should intra-entity transfers be eliminated before the cap is applied?
  9. One month, capped or uncapped? Paragraph 6.4 asks insurers to show liquidity sources cover needs over one month, using cumulative stressed net cash flows. Paragraph 7.4 caps inflows at 75% of outflows for the ILR. The guidance notice's table uses uncapped cumulative figures for the ladder and the capped figure only for the ILR. Is that the intended reading?
  10. Opening bank balance and HQLA. The return's cumulative rows start from an "Opening Bank Balance", and cash and demand deposits are also HQLA line 91. Guidance 7.9 says an asset should not be counted twice. Should the opening balance be left out of the cumulative position when the cash is in the HQLA?
  11. The guidance notice's days to exhaustion. In its illustrative table, the ILRs follow from the printed cumulative figures (100/91 = 110%, 100/125 = 80%, 100/133 = 75%, 100/250 = 40%), but the days to exhaustion do not. For the cyberattack case, 22% used by day 7 and 125% by day 30 gives about day 24 on a straight line; the table says day 20. What interpolation did the PA use? The calculator states its own: straight line inside the bucket.
  12. Start date and transition. No commencement date is set, but the monthly return depends on systems and data the PA's own statement of need says insurers are worried about. Is a phase-in or a parallel-run period planned?

Sources

Open the calculator